Make My Payment: A Bold Idea That Faced Shark Tank India's Toughest Criticism

2/2/2025

The latest episode of Shark Tank India - Season 4 featured an innovative yet controversial pitch by Make My Payment, an automated payment reminder system designed to help individuals and businesses track and recover dues. While the founders presented their vision with confidence, they faced strong criticism from the sharks, making this pitch one of the most debated in the show’s history.


Meet the Founders

The company was founded by:

  • Vijay Nihalchandani (Young, Male)
  • Chirag Nihalchandani (Young, Male)
  • Pooja Nagdewani (Young, Female)
  • Kapil Dave (Young, Male)

They hail from Ujjain, Madhya Pradesh, and believe their platform can revolutionize the way MSMEs and individuals track and collect payments.


What is Make My Payment?

Make My Payment is an automatic payment reminder system that sends automated calls, messages, and emails to help businesses and individuals recover outstanding payments.

Key Features:

✅ Available for both individuals and businesses
✅ Automated calls, SMS, and emails
✅ Multiple pricing plans for different user needs

The Founders’ Claim:

🔹 “80% of MSMEs in India rely on informal credit for their operations.”
🔹 The app aims to simplify debt recovery and help businesses stay financially healthy.


The Ask & Business Model

💰 Ask: ₹30 Lakhs for 3% equity (₹10 Crore valuation)

📅 Launched: July 2024
📈 Users: 3,500 (700 successfully recovered their debts)
📊 Paid Users: 6% of total users
📱 Total Downloads: 5,700
💰 Lifetime Sales: ₹30,000

Pricing Plans:

Plan Calls SMS Emails Price
Free 50 50 50 ₹0
Basic 125 125 125 ₹99
Pro 300 300 300 ₹199
Premium 800 800 800 ₹699

📞 Calls are made using multiple numbers to increase reach.


Sharks’ Reactions & Tough Criticism

Anupam Mittal (Harsh Criticism)

❌ * 'This is not a business, guys! Just be serious. This is just workflow automation that anyone can do.'*
❌ He strongly criticized the model and said it lacked scalability and uniqueness.

Namita Thapar (Rejected the Pitch)

“Money cannot be made with this application. Stop this business and focus on something meaningful.”

Aman Gupta & Ritesh Agarwal (Rejected the Pitch)

❌ Both sharks opted out, saying the business lacked strong monetization potential.

Peyush Bansal vs. Anupam Mittal - Heated Debate

🔥 Peyush Bansal appreciated the founders for their entrepreneurial spirit, especially because Vijay is a content creator with 1 million Instagram followers.
🔥 Anupam strongly disagreed, arguing that being an influencer does not mean you can run a successful business.

🚨 Final Verdict:
❌ All sharks rejected the deal, and the founders left without funding.


Final Thoughts

While Make My Payment introduced a promising solution for MSMEs, it failed to convince the sharks due to:
Lack of differentiation in the market
Limited revenue potential
High competition in workflow automation

Despite the rejection, the founders remain committed to their vision. Will they prove the sharks wrong in the future? Only time will tell!

🔗 Company Website: [N/A]